Why Aren't There More Pugs in Movies?

Think about the number of dogs you see in films. Since the days of Charlie Chaplin's A Dog's Life, man's best friend has been a staple on the silver screen, whether in classics like Homeward Bound or contemporary box office smashes like A Dog's Purpose. One of the year's best-kept secrets is a film simply titled "Dog." It's not uncommon to see German Shepherds or Golden Retrievers in feature films, with a few exceptions, such as Marry Me, Dick, or The Game Plan, where they serve as a supporting comedic relief role. Pugs, on the other hand, are conspicuously missing from this depiction. It's a mystery to me why this gorgeous canine species is so seldom included in mainstream cinematic releases.

For the most part, the lack of pugs in movies may be explained by the features they appear in. While one pug had a key role as the pet of the film's title character, another appeared in the film version of Jane Austen's Mansfield Park. There's a sense of historical or literary accuracy in the inclusion of pugs in these productions. The disappearance of Marie Antoinette's beloved pugs would have sparked a public outcry. Not to diminish the importance of these cinematic pugs, but rather to highlight how movies with pugs in them tend to have external causes influencing their existence.


It is interesting to note that pugs are often utilized to indicate that a film is set in either the past or future. In today's world, the mere existence of this creature onscreen might instantly imply to the viewer that they are seeing something set in a different time period or universe. This may be done by using pugs for blink-and-miss-it appearances in high fantasy films like The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug. In the meanwhile, futuristic films like Isle of Dogs, Dune, and Brazil use pugs as a shorthand for the "weirdness" of an uncertain future. As a result, modern-day pugs aren't as common as they used to be in the past.



In the modern world, even films like Men in Black employ pugs as a visual cue to indicate abnormality. In this title, Frank, the legendary cinematic pug, may be found. Once again, a pug serves as a visual shorthand for an anomaly from the "normal" environment in this mouthy extraterrestrial figure. Every time a pug shows up, it's a symbol of absurdity, no matter what historical period. There's a reason they can't simply come up at random places: Even in realistic dramas like Richard Linklater or Jim Jarmusch, the visual coding for pugs has grown so widespread and indelible that it has a potential to upend the piece's controlled realism.



In part, the lack of popularity of pugs is why they've been used in movies so often. Among the most popular dog breeds in 2021, the American Kennel Club lists a diverse range of canines in the top spots. This includes German shepherds, poodles, and even corgis, who are known for their unusual breeds. There were no Pugs in the top three, but Shetland sheepdogs and border collies did make it into the top thirty-three. As long as pugs remained America's most popular dog breed, movie companies would be more likely to take advantage of a large audience. In light of the fact that pugs are now ranked low on the popularity scale for dogs, there is little incentive to modify their cinematic representation.


Also, pugs are known for their odd appearance, which has led to their frequent usage as a symbol for weird situations and circumstances. Pugs are a mix between an anatomical nightmare and an attractive sausage, with smushed noses, fat tummies, and eyes so enormous that they seem like billiard balls. That is great for cuddling or simply watching them run about, but not for Hollywood's expectations for dogs in terms of appearance. Canines, like human stars, face a high hurdle when it comes to being deemed "suitable" to star in major motion movies.



Because they seem more "natural," dogs like German shepherds and golden retrievers are often used in film projects because their grunting and snoring won't overpower the film's audio. The breeds listed above can also do impressive physical feats with ease. Think about how many dog movies, like The Call of the Wild or Marley & Me, are based on larger-sized live-action or CGI dogs that can jump over trees or sprint across wheat fields without taking a breath.. Imagine any of the famous canine movie plots being performed by a pug.. Having a pug at the heart of one of these movies is possible, but it would need a major shift in Hollywood's canine movie paradigm. Movies often exclude pugs from the cast because of the restricted concept of a "legitimate" canine protagonist.



And there's that pug-related dispute, notably that pugs' particular look and physical attributes are the product of breeding that make daily living a misery for pugs. As a consequence, groups like PETA have criticized Vodafone for employing pugs in its adverts, arguing that the company's frivolous usage of pugs minimizes the problems pugs face on a daily basis. Constant PETA-related criticism is suspicious at best because of PETA's own canine-handling controversies. For executives at movie studios, however, the possibility of a public relations nightmare due to the difficulties associated with producing pugs does not improve the image of these dogs.



In film history, only a small number of pugs have managed to get it to the big time, like Frank from Men in Black or Monchi from The Mitchell vs. The Machines. Since then, these dogs have shown the variety of amusement they can provide for people. Even though pugs deserve a consistent cinematic spotlight, they're held back by a multitude of factors. In contrast to German shepherds and golden retrievers, pugs are normally used only in biopics or to imply that a movie takes place in a "weird" environment. Perhaps in the future, there will be a broad range of films in which pugs appear, a reflection of how diverse the personalities of pugs are.



Until then, pug fans will have to settle with Frank, Monchi, and of course, the Saturday Night Live segment about pug wigs.